I am often asked the question of what difference there is between the various types of deeds used in Texas, as well as which one my client should use (or request that the seller use if my client is the buyer). In order to understand which is preferable, a potential buyer or seller of real property inTexas needs to understand the difference:
General Warranty Deed:
A Texas general warranty deed is the traditional type of deed used in Texas. Most people do not realize that when they execute a deed, they are not simply conveying the property or transferring title to the property to the buyer, but they are also warranting and agreeing to forever defend title to the property. The seller, or grantor, is giving a warranty to the buyer, or grantee, that she has good and marketable title to the property, subject to certain exceptions listed in the deed and any reservations by the seller. Essentially, this means that if the buyer later encounters problems with the title to the property, the seller is obligated to defend the buyer’s title to the property. More specifically, under a Texas General Warranty Deed, the seller, or grantor, is agreeing to warrant and forever defend all and singular the property to the grantee and the grantee’s heirs, successors, and assigns against every person whomsoever lawfully claiming or to claim the same or any part thereof.
Special Warranty Deed:
Similarly, the seller, or grantor, under a Texas Special Warranty Deed is also agreeing to warrant and forever defend the property to the grantee, or buyer, against every person whomsoever lawfully claiming or to claim the same or any part thereof, however, the warranty under a special warranty deed is limited to only those claims that are made by, through, or under grantor but not otherwise. Basically, if the grantor, or seller, sold the property to someone else, encumbered the property in some way, or took some other action giving rise to someone else’ claim in the property, then he will defend. However, under a Special Warranty Deed, the seller is not obligated to defend title to the property against people whose claim arose through an owner prior to the grantor.
Quitclaim Deed:
Finally, on occasion I have clients who think a quitclaim deed is the most appropriate deed, such as when two owners of property decide that one is going to convey his or her interest in the property to the other. However, I very rarely recommend that such a type of deed be used, as a standard quitclaim deed is really not a deed at all. Instead, it is simply a release by the person that he or she will not claim title to the property. Depending on the wording of the quitclaim, at times it does not even use the word convey or transfer, and it does not warrant title to the property. Accordingly, using a quitclaim deed can often cause problems later when the owner goes to sell the property to a third party who wants to get title insurance on the property. Therefore, the limited situation where I have, at times, recommended a quitclaim deed is when title to the property is not actually in the name of an individual (but possibly in a trust instead), but the buyer is wanting to make sure that none of the beneficiaries to the trust later claim title to the property after the sale by the trust to the buyer. In such a situation, it could be appropriate to have the beneficiaries sign a quitclaim deed.
So which should I use? The answer of which is preferable depends on whether it is the buyer or seller who is asking.
For the seller, the less he is agreeing to warrant and defend the property, the better. He understandably wants to limit his future liability for any problems with the title, especially if they are problems that are due to actions taken by prior owners and not by him. Therefore, it is very common in commercial transactions in particular, but also in residential transactions involving more savvy sellers, for the seller to agree to only give a special warranty deed.
For the buyer, the greater warranty and protection he can get from the seller, the better. Accordingly, the buyer usually would prefer a general warranty deed, and in many residential transactions, the seller is agreeable to such a deed. Interestingly, the Texas Real Estate Commission form contract for a 1 to 4 family residential property does provide for a general warranty deed, as that is the traditional type of deed used in residential closings.
Can I wait until closing to worry about what kind of deed we will use?
You can, but you won’t be able to do much about it at that point. The type of deed that will be provided is usually specified in the contract that is initially executed by the buyer and seller. Therefore, this is one of many reasons why it is helpful to consult a lawyer before you even execute the purchase contract. While many people believe they do not need a lawyer, if at all, until they go to closing, much of the closing documents are dictated by the terms of the contract. If the buyer or seller has already signed a contract agreeing to terms contrary to what his or her lawyer later advises him or her, there is often very little anyone can do at that point to change the terms, unless both sides are agreeable.